The Shelves

Mystery & Detective Collections & Anthologies Fiction Books

Evidence-led mystery & detective collections & anthologies fiction selections grounded in fiction signal quality, reader intent fit, and cross-source metadata agreement.

10 picksLast refreshed 2026-03-03Copy link

1. The Best American Mystery Stories 2020
C.J. Box, Otto Penzler
Fits this list for its focus on anthologies and collections.
2. The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2024
S.A. Cosby, Steph Cha
Fits this list for its focus on fiction and mystery.
3. The Mysterious Bookshop Presents the Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2021
Lee Child, Otto Penzler
Fits this list for its focus on fiction and mystery.
4. The Best American Mystery Stories 2010
Lee Child
Fits this list for its focus on anthologies and collections.
5. The Best American Mystery Stories 2009
Jeffery Deaver, Otto Penzler
Fits this list for its focus on anthologies and collections.
6. The Whole Art of Detection
Lyndsay Faye
Fits this list for its focus on anthologies and collections.
7. The Best American Mystery Stories 2001
Lawrence Block, Otto Penzler
Fits this list for its focus on anthologies and collections.
8. The Best American Mystery Stories 2019
Jonathan Lethem, Otto Penzler
Fits this list for its focus on fiction and mystery.
9. Who Do You Think You Are?
Hazel Rochman, Darlene Z. McCampbell
Fits this list for its focus on anthologies and collections.
10. The Best American Mystery Stories 2014
Otto Penzler, Laura Lippman
Fits this list for its focus on fiction and mystery.

Browse Related Genres