The Shelves

Thrillers Supernatural Books

Books selected for readers looking for thrillers supernatural books.

53 booksApril 2, 2026

Part of 470+ tracked lists·2 crossover shelves·90% reader overlap with Fantasy Paranormal Books

1. Ghost Eaters
Clay Chapman, Clay McLeod Chapman
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
2. A Head Full of Ghosts
Paul Tremblay
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural.
Shelf signal: Psychological Horror
3. Night Watcher
Daphne Woolsoncroft, Helen Laser
Included for strong book club alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Psychological Horror
4. Between Two Fires
Christopher Buehlman
Included for strong book club alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Horror
5. The Bad Weather Friend
Dean Koontz, Ray Chase
Included for strong book club alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
6. The Ghosts of Gwendolyn Montgomery
Brittany Bradford, André Santana
Included for strong adventure alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Hispanic & Latino Fantasy
7. The Found Object Society
Michelle Maryk
Included for strong thriller alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Sci-Fi Crime
8. Ring Shout
P. Djèlí Clark
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural.
Shelf signal: Dark Fantasy
9. The Buffalo Hunter Hunter
Stephen Graham Jones
Included for strong book club alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Indigenous Horror
10. Awakened
Laura Elliott
Included for strong science alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Apocalyptic & Post-Apocalyptic
11. Firestarter
Stephen King, Dennis Boutsikaris
Included for strong thriller alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
12. Atlas of Paranormal Places
Evelyn Hollow
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural.
Shelf signal: Haunted Places & Mysteries
13. Nightstruck
Jenna Black
Included for strong romantic alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Urban Fantasy
14. The Country Will Bring US No Peace
Matthieu Simard, Pablo Strauss
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural and thrillers.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
15. The Macabre
Kosoko Jackson
Included for strong black alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Dark Fantasy
16. They Fear Not Men in the Woods
Gretchen McNeil, Justis Bolding
Included for strong horror alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
17. Supernatural: Witch's Canyon
Jeff Mariotte, Jeffrey J. Mariotte
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
18. 20th Century Ghosts
Joe Hill
Included for strong short story alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Supernatural Thrillers
19. The 49th Mystic
Ted Dekker, Alyssa Bresnahan
Included for strong series alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Christian Fantasy
20. The Croning
Laird Barron
Included for strong horror alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Dark Fantasy
21. The Stalking
Heather Graham
Included for strong dark alignment with this thrillers supernatural list.
Shelf signal: Romantic Suspense
22. The Girl With All the Gifts
M. R. Carey
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural and thrillers.
Shelf signal: YA Survival Stories
23. The Horror at Red Hook
H. P. Lovecraft
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural and thrillers.
Shelf signal: Gothic Romance
24. Mask of Death
Paul Ernst
Fits this list for its focus on supernatural and thrillers.
Shelf signal: Hard-Boiled Mystery